Sign In
APEC Project Database

Project Title

Women in Standards: Reducing Inequality

Project Year

2023

Project Number

SCSC_205_2023A

Project Session

Session 2

Project Type

Standard

Project Status

Withdrawn Project

Project No.

SCSC_205_2023A

Project Title

*
Women in Standards: Reducing Inequality

Project Status

Withdrawn Project

Fund Account

*
APEC Support Fund

Sub-fund

ASF: General Fund

Project Year

2023

Project Session

*
Session 2

APEC Funding

109,788

Co-funding Amount

0

Total Project Value

109,788

Sponsoring Forum

*
Sub-Committee on Standards and Conformance (SCSC)

Topics

Conformance; Standards and Conformance; Gender

Committee

Committee on Trade and Investment (CTI)

Other Fora Involved

Other Non-APEC Stakeholders Involved

 

Proposing Economy(ies)

United States

Co-Sponsoring Economies

Australia; Canada; Malaysia; Mexico; New Zealand; Peru; Philippines; Singapore; Chinese Taipei; Viet Nam

Expected Start Date

01/03/2024

Expected Completion Date

30/06/2025

Project Proponent Name 1

Kent Shigetomi

Job Title 1

Director, Multilateral Non-Tariff Barriers

Organization 1

Office of the US Trade Representative

Telephone 1

+1-202-395-9459

Email 1

Project Proponent Name 2

Not Applicable

Job Title 2

Not Applicable

Organization 2

Not Applicable

Telephone 2

Not Applicable

Email 2

Not Applicable

Declaration

Kent Shigetomi

Project Summary

Relevant international standards are critical for trade. By providing a common reference point, standards reduce transaction costs, allowing a good produced in one economy to be sold in multiple economies. International standards contribute to the safety, reliability and efficiency of products. However, standards are largely developed by and for men, which influences the standard itself. When involved in an auto accident, women are 73%more likely to be injured or die because safety standards have been developed to protect a male body. Voice recognition technologies are more responsive to male voices than female voices. If more women were engaged in standards development, the resulting standards are more likely to reflect women’s input. We will examine the reasons why women participate less in standards development. We will also review steps that economies and organizations can take to account for sex and gender differences in standards.

Relevance

Region

A report from the OECD argued that in order for societies to benefit from gender parity, they must first address discriminatory social institutions, which are increasingly seen as the root cause of gender inequality. Such social institutions include formal and informal law, policies and regulations, as well as social norms and practices that limit women’s access to opportunities and their rights. In the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) Declaration for Gender Responsive Standards and Standards Development, signatories committed to “acknowledge that representation of women in standards development is almost always below parity and that the outcomes for men and women are not explicitly addressed during the standards development process.” Signatories committed to take action to ensure standards are gender responsive.

Standards specify how to do, test, or identify something. They have been referred to as invisible infrastructure, and while they are pervasive (impacting the products, processes and services we use daily), they often go unnoticed. They are developed by panels of experts using a consensus approach. As the gender declaration acknowledges, women are under-represented in standardization. Extrapolating from other domains, it seems obvious that the under-representation of women in standardization will have consequences. Indeed, there is compelling evidence that standards are not protecting women as well as they are protecting men. When standards are incorporated into technical regulations they become mandatory, which could compound the problem.

Eligibility and Fund Priorities

This concept note seeks funding from the APEC Support Fund – General Fund, which will be used to provide capacity building on how to ensure standards development and technical regulations are gender responsive. International work to incorporate women’s concerns into standards development is a relatively new, but continuing area of work. In earlier SCSC workshops, the only presentations related to gender and standards were made by developed economies. This indicates that developing economies do not yet have the capability to consider gender and/or sex in standards. This makes the concept note directly relevant to two of the fund’s areas of work, developing human capital and strengthening economic infrastructure.

Under “developing human capital,” the project aims to integrate women into standards work, and to address women in individual standards development. This is directly related to the goals of “broadening economic growth” to address the needs of an underserved group. The project is also tied to “strengthen social cohesion domestically and regionally.” As women are integrated into standards and technical regulatory development, they become part of a broader international framework. A second part of the Manila Framework seeks to “strengthen economic infrastructure” by eliminating bottlenecks to growth. By integrating women into standards development, we hope to account for sex and gender differences in standards and open wider opportunities in international standards work.

Capacity Building

All APEC economies either participate in international standards development or work to produce their own domestic standards. In either instance, regulators and standards developers must both be cognizant of sex and gender differences in order to achieve the desired objective. If they fail to do so, then the standard or technical regulation is less effective and may not meet the desired public policy outcome.

Objectives

This project has two objectives. First, it aims to collect and share information on women’s participation in standards-related activities, in order to identify barriers that economies face and strategies to address them. Economies will be able to better support women’s education and career development. Second, the project will share information on how gender is addressed in standards and technical regulation development. By doing so, economies will become more aware of how they can address gender differences in standards to ensure that resulting policies are more inclusive. They will be able to produce standards and technical regulations that are gender responsive and do not discriminate based on gender. These actions directly contribute to the advancement of the La Serena Roadmap.

Alignment

APEC

This project works to implement the guidance outlined in the 2011 declaration of the APEC High-Level Policy Dialogue on Women and the Economy and the 2019 La Serena Roadmap. The 2011 declaration points out that women “face barriers to full access to and participation in education and training.” The declaration calls on officials to “encourage the empowerment of women and remove discriminatory practices which inhibit women’s capacity and ability to build their skills.” This project will seek to identify barriers that inhibit women’s participation in standards-related activities and ways to address them. Economies will be asked to share actions they have taken to promote involvement.

This project advances several areas of the La Serena Roadmap. Key Action Area B, on “strengthening women’s labor force participation,” outlines way to increase economic engagement. Individual bullet points encourage economies to “take measures, such as structural reforms, to create an enabling environment for women to participate in the economy, including by reducing barriers and enhancing protections in policies, laws, regulations and practices.” The roadmap also recommends “promot[ing] the recruitment, hiring, retention, and advancement of women in all sectors, especially in higher-wage, high-growth sectors. Key Action Area E, “advancing women’s economic empowerment through data collection and analysis,” asks economies to “strengthen statistical capacity … to better produce, collect, analyze and disseminate sex- disaggregated statistics.” This project will aim to collect and share existing data on the consequences of differences in gender in standards.

Forum
Article 2.1 of the SCSC Terms of Reference (TOR) outlines the committee’s objectives. The first objective states that the SCSC will work to “reduce technical barriers to trade and enhance market access through standards and conformance...” If the standards or technical regulations of one economy unfairly discriminate between genders, then products produced in another economy may not be able to sold there. In addition, women in the first economy may be at risk of physical harm in the case of an accident because safety standards do not adequately account for sex and/or gender differences. Article 2.1.7 of the SCSC TOR states that the committee shall “promote and encourage participation in standards and conformance education and awareness programs…” The issue of the relationship of gender to standards and technical regulations is relatively new. In order for the work to be most effective all economies should be involved. The project aims to address knowledge gaps so all economies can participate.

Outputs

1) Pre-Workshop Survey and Questionnaire

The project overseer will conduct an online, pre-workshop questionnaire that will aim to determine the extent to which economies understand the role that sex and gender play in standards development, and how economies consider gender issues when developing or modifying standards. For those economies that identify technical assistance as a priority, the survey will seek to determine the specific areas where assistance might be required.

The workshop program may be adjusted to reflect the specific challenges that economies face. The results will be used primarily to shape the project event (e.g., topics, speakers), and notable findings will be shared with workshop participants and the SCSC. We do not intend to produce any written output of the survey results.

2) Workshop

The main focus of the project is to organize and stage a two-day in-person workshop in Korea, on the margins of SCSC 1 (February 2025). The workshop will include sessions that identify the ways in which gender issues may require standards or regulations to be modified to account for gender differences. The results of the pre-workshop questionnaire will be used to identify the areas of specific interest to economies.

The panels will discuss the degree to which gender has been incorporated in economies’ standards development and how the analysis was conducted, presentations on global efforts to incorporate gender, and steps that economies can take to begin the process. 

Key findings from the pre-workshop questionnaire will be shared with participants and reported to the SCSC. At the end of the workshop, key findings and conclusions will be identified and highlighted for participants. We will also survey participants to determine areas for future work.

Specific panels may examine:

- International efforts by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO), the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC), ASTM International, and other domestic/international standards developers on the work that has taken place.

- Presentations by individual economies on their work to incorporate gender into standards development.

- Possible impact on domestic and international manufacturers of goods

- Role of training and certification of professionals on sex/gender issues.

3) Project Summary Report

An electronic report of minimum of 4 pages (excluding annexes) that will be available to all economies will be developed at the end of the workshop. It will contain the executive summary, information on the experts/speakers involved, key discussions based on experts/speakers’ materials/presentations and questions-and-answer session, key recommendations, conclusion and annexes which may include agenda, pre-event assessment/post-event evaluation results and other relevant information as appropriate. These materials will be e-mailed to participants and will be made available in the APEC website. It is not expected to be an official APEC publication. Recommendations for future work will be prepared as part of the report guided by the discussions/results of the workshop. The project overseer will also survey and compile feedback from participants, especially input related to possible areas for future capacity-building activities.

Outcomes
1) The key outcome of this project is the enhanced ability of regulators in APEC economies to understand and consider sex and gender differences into the development of standards. Regulators will learn from international standards organizations and other economies who have taken steps to implement gender-responsiveness into their standards.

2) This workshop will demonstrate to officials in APEC economies the policy consequences of not considering gender differences into standards and make them aware of cooperative international efforts that economies may participate in. This will hopefully lead to greater international cooperation and experience sharing.

3) Economies who require technical assistance to achieve their public policy goals will have the opportunity to engage with standards developing organizations and international bodies. This may facilitate future work.

4) As more economies become engaged in this work, this will lead to higher quality standards that consider sex and gender differences. This can contribute to greater health and safety.

Beneficiaries and Outputs

Beneficiaries

The ideal government participants are regulators and standards developers. These officials have the responsibility for promoting or ensuring public safety. We aim to engage them in order to convey the importance of incorporating gender considerations in their work. Ideally, standards developers should have responsibility for ensuring standards are gender responsive. Regulators should be engaged in public safety, public health, or other areas where gender-related differences may exist.

We note that in some economies, standards are developed in the private sector or by quasi-governmental organizations. We will reach out to the appropriate standards development bodies in economies to identify the appropriate participants.

The ideal speakers would be standards developers and policy managers. These officials would have the practical knowledge of how standards affect business and how to make changes to standards. By having a commonality of speakers and participants both engaged in the same activity, we believe the benefits will be increased. Policy managers who are responsible for gender activities within their economy would also benefit because they could learn about how to apply standards as a policy tool to achieve positive outcomes. There is no ideal set of qualifications for participants, but they should have knowledge and experience with developing standards in their economy. 

We will invite officials from international standards development organizations (SDO) who have experience with multilateral work on gender and standards. Some of the relevant groups are the International Standards Organization (ISO), the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC), ASTM International, all of whom are participants in the SCSC. These groups will be able to provide a broad perspective of the scope of work that has already been conducted. 

Women will actively participate in the planning, management, allocation of resources, and implementation of the project and will play key roles in planning the conference. The project overseer will actively encourage the participation of women in the conference, including as presenters at the conference. The project seeks to have women represent at least 50 percent of the workshop participants and speakers.

Dissemination

The results of the workshop will be captured into a Project Summary Report that can be published electronically on the APEC Project Database and/or the Meeting Documents Database for members’ reference. The electronic publication will include the workshop agenda, presentations, curricula vitae of speakers and a summary report of the workshop. This information will be accessible to the public following the workshop to ensure that only updated information is reflected therein. 

Channels of dissemination: Only the APEC website will be used to share workshop results. 

The target audience: The target audience would include government regulators, organizations that develop standards or conformity assessment procedures, and representatives of trade associations. 

Any intention to sell outputs arising from this project: There is no intention to sell the outputs arising from this project. Member economies will be encouraged to disseminate results of the workshop with their respective agencies and business communities through their websites.

Gender

Please see Project Proposal in Supporting Documents folder.

Work Plan

Please see Project Proposal in Supporting Documents folder.

Risks

Please see Project Proposal in Supporting Documents folder.

Monitoring and Evaluation

Please see Project Proposal in Supporting Documents folder.

Linkages

The Committee on Trade and Investment and the Policy Partnership on Women and the Economy is likely to have an interest in this work. The Project Overseer gave a presentation to a joint meeting of those two groups on the project at SOM 3 in Seattle. We will also reach out to other bodies, such as the Policy Partnership on Science, Technology and Innovation to invite them to participate. 

We would also engage international standardization bodies to solicit information on the progress made to date, as well as the challenges that remain. The International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC), who have jointly issued guidance for technical committees on gender responsive standards, as well as domestic standards bodies are good candidates for engagement. The United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) issued the 2019 “Declaration for Gender Responsive Standards and Standards Development.” That body may also be interested in participating.

Sustainability

Please see Project Proposal in Supporting Documents folder.

Direct Labour

Not Applicable.

Are there any supporting document attached?

Yes
Project No.
Project Title
Project Status
Fund Account
Sub-fund
Project Year
Project Session
APEC Funding
Co-funding Amount
Total Project Value
Sponsoring Forum
Topics
Committee
Other Fora Involved
Other Non-APEC Stakeholders Involved
Proposing Economy(ies)
Co-Sponsoring Economies
Expected Start Date
Expected Completion Date
Project Proponent Name 1
Job Title 1
Organization 1
Telephone 1
Email 1
Project Proponent Name 2
Job Title 2
Organization 2
Telephone 2
Email 2
Declaration
Project Summary
Relevance
Objectives
Alignment
Beneficiaries and Outputs
Dissemination
Gender
Work Plan
Risks
Monitoring and Evaluation
Linkages
Sustainability
Direct Labour
Are there any supporting document attached?
hdFldAdmin
Project Number
Previous Fora
Secretariat Comments
Reprogramming Notes
Consolidated QAF
Endorsement By Fora
PD Sign Off
Batch
Forum Priority
Committee Ranking Category
Committee Priority
PDM Priority
Priority Within Funding Category
Monitoring Report Received
Completion Report Received
PMU Field 1
PMU Field 2
PMU Field 3
On Behalf Of
Proposal Status
Originating Sub-Forum
Primary Driver
Primary Objective
Secondary Driver
Secondary Objective
Approval Status
Attachments
Content Type: Standard Proposal