Sign In
APEC Project Database

Project Title

Conversion of coal-fired power plants using Energy Storage System: experiences, challenges, and opportunities

Project Year

2023

Project Number

EWG_206_2023A

Project Session

Session 2

Project Type

Standard

Project Status

Completed Project

Project No.

EWG_206_2023A

Project Title

*
Conversion of coal-fired power plants using Energy Storage System: experiences, challenges, and opportunities

Project Status

Completed Project

Fund Account

*
APEC Support Fund

Sub-fund

ASF: Energy Efficiency, Low Carbon and Energy Resiliency Measures (EELCER)

Project Year

2023

Project Session

*
Session 2

APEC Funding

96,905

Co-funding Amount

5,500

Total Project Value

102,405

Sponsoring Forum

*
Energy Working Group (EWG)

Topics

Energy; Digital Economy; Environment

Committee

SOM Steering Committee on Economic and Technical Cooperation (SCE)

Other Fora Involved

Other Non-APEC Stakeholders Involved

 

Proposing Economy(ies)

Chile

Co-Sponsoring Economies

Canada; Hong Kong, China; Korea; United States

Expected Start Date

01/01/2024

Expected Completion Date

30/06/2025

Project Proponent Name 1

Adelaida Baeriswyl Concha

Job Title 1

PO

Organization 1

Ministry of Energy, Chile

Telephone 1

+562 2367 3732

Email 1

Project Proponent Name 2

Pablo del Canto

Job Title 2

PO

Organization 2

Ministry of Energy, Chile

Telephone 2

Not Applicable

Email 2

Declaration

Adelaida Baeriswyl Concha

Project Summary

One of the APEC 2023 United States priorities is “innovation”, which means enabling an innovative environment for a sustainable future. To this end, the project seeks to take targeted measures to enhance climate change mitigation and resilience. The energy transition by renewable energy sources and Energy Storage Systems (ESS) is in line with this priority. Indeed, ESS provide security, stability, and flexibility to renewable energy systems, characterized by high production variability. They can therefore contribute to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and slowing down thepace of climate change. In this perspective, the project corresponds to a two-day in-person seminar in Santiago, Chile, which will address experiences, challenges, and opportunities related to the conversion of coal-fired power plants in APEC economies through ESS. After the seminar, a summary report will be prepared and published on the APEC website, containing the main findings and recommendations from the presentations.

Relevance

Benefits to Region: The United Nations′ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) agrees that continued emissions of greenhouse gases, such as those produced by thermoelectricpower plants, will lead to increased global warming. The effects are already visible. They include heavy rainfall, floods, severe droughts, increased forest fires, melting polar ice caps, loss of biodiversity, and increased costs for all economies to deal with these impacts.
Global warming could be slowed by deep, rapid, and sustained reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, for example by retiring or retrofitting thermal powerplants. In this regard, about two-thirds of APEC economies plan to retire coal-fired power plants by 2030 and 2040 (Australia; Canada; Chile; China; Hong Kong, China; Indonesia; Japan; Malaysia; Mexico; New Zealand; Russia; Korea; Singapore; Thailand; and the United States), and nine members are in the process (Australia; Canada; Chile; China; Hong Kong, China; Japan; Russia; Singapore; and the United States). Conversion of this type of facility allows the reuse of existing infrastructure ,helps to sustain local economies, and retains some of the workforce. This reduces environmental, economic, and social impacts.
The project will enable APEC economies to re-engage, share knowledge, innovate, and develop technical skills on the experiences, challenges, and opportunities associated with retrofitting thermoelectric power plants with ESS through a two-day face-to-face seminar in Santiago, Chile, and a summary report. This information will be helpful for economies that have not yet started the process, as well as for those economies that are well advanced. Indeed, economies will be able to develop technical knowledge to improve or create their policies and/or regulations based on the experiences of others. In addition, the project can help to develop new business opportunities among APEC members.

Eligibility and Fund Priorities: The project is in line with the priorities of the APEC “Energy Efficiency, Low Carbon and Energy Resiliency Measures” (EELCER) Support Fund by enabling and increasing the share of renewable energy by improving the security and stability of the electricity supply through ESS. At the same time, economies will have more tools to achieve the energy transition by retrofitting coal-fired power plants, improving the security and stability of the electricity supply, reducing greenhouse gas emissions, and thereby minimizing the impact of climate change.
The project also develops capacity building, facilitates technology and information flows, and harnesses future technologies through the economies' experience in implementing ESS for thermoelectric power plant retrofits. As noted above, more than two-thirds of APEC economies have plans to retire thermoelectric power plants, which will require various measures to enable the electricity system to operate based on renewable energy sources.

Capacity Building: The seminar will provide a formal opportunity that allows for face-to-face interaction and networking among experts and participants. Attendants from APEC economies will acquire, share, strengthen, maintain, and develop knowledge to improve their policies and regulations related to the conversion of coal-fired power plants to ESS. In addition, a summary report of key findings and recommendations will be published on the APEC website.
More than two-thirds of APEC economies have plans to retire coal-fired power plants by 2040, and seven of these economies are considered APEC developing economies. More than two-thirds of APEC economies have plans to retire coal-fired power plants by 2040, and seven of these economies are considered APEC developing economies (Chile; China; Indonesia; Malaysia; Mexico; Thailand; and Russia). For this group, the importance of coal as a fuel for power generation varies from more than 70%(Malaysia) to 18% (Russia). All these developing economies will benefit from the project.
The summary report will provide guidance for the transition to decarbonization, allowing each economy to move at its own pace. It is important to note that the project is not intended to be prescriptive, but rather a tool that can be used as a reference for the development of public policies and regulatory adjustments. At the same time, APEC members who do not plan to retire power plants may be interested in developing policies and regulations to address this issue. In terms of APEC's capacity-building objectives, all of the above APEC economies, as well as those members that produce ESS, can benefit from the project as it promotes innovation, and equitable development and reduces economic disparities by democratizing access to information. It also deepens the sense of community as it is an event in which all APEC economies can participate. The project can create new business opportunities; and, in the case of the conversion of coal-fired power plants, it can improve the long-term economic and social welfare of the population by providing an alternative use for existing infrastructure and reducing emissions. Finally, the project will be inclusive and will not discriminate against participants on the basis of gender, ethnicity, age, sexual orientation, disability, or socioeconomic status.


Objectives

The project’s objective is to develop the innovation and human capital of APEC economies in relation to the experiences, challenges, and opportunities of converting coal-fired power plants through the implementation of Energy Storage Systems. Members will be able to develop technical knowledge to improve or establish their policies and regulations based on the experiences of others. At the same time, economies will have more tools to achieve the energy transition, increase the security and stability of the electricity supply, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and thereby minimize the impact of climate change.

Expected outcomes include (1) the acquisition of technical knowledge, (2) the promotion of policy design and regulatory development, and (3) the creation of business opportunities among APEC economies.

Alignment

APEC: APEC 2023 United States Priorities: The project is in line with the “Innovation” priority, as it promotes the energy transition to clean energy by renewable energy sources and Energy Storage Systems (ESS). Indeed, ESS provide security, stability, and flexibility to renewable energy systems, characterized by high production variability. They can therefore contribute to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and slowing down the pace of climate change.
APEC Putrajaya 2040 Vision: Firstly, the project aligns with Driver 3 "Strong, Balanced, Secure, Sustainable and Inclusive Growth" by promoting innovation, cooperation, human capital development, and growth that will support global efforts to comprehensively address environmental challenges for a sustainable planet. Secondly, the project aligns with Driver 2 “Innovation and Digitalization” by pursuing policy reforms to promote innovation and develop technical skills in retrofitting coal-fired power plants with ESS, which is a new alternative use for energy assets. This will  enable technical cooperation through the exchange of best practice policies that address these environmental challenges, support sustainable growth, and increase prosperity and welfare for all by reducing greenhouse gas emissions through the conversion of thermoelectric power plants.
APEC APA Objectives: The project addresses the "Human Resource Development and Skills for the Future" objective by promoting the development of participants′ technical skills on the experiences, challenges, and opportunities of coal-fired powerplant retrofits.

Forum: The project is in line with the objectives of the Energy Working Group by promoting the development of renewable energy sources, energy security measures, and the development of innovation, and human capital in APEC economies to facilitate the conversion of coal-fired power plants through the implementation of ESS. Besides, the project can strengthen cooperation among the APEC economies by sharing experiences on the topic.
In addition, the project is in line with the objectives of the Strategic Plan 2019 – 2023of the Energy Working Group, in particular by sharing best practices, lessons learned, barriers, policies, and regulatory frameworks related to the conversion of coal-fired power plants through the implementation of ESS. Both the seminar and the summary report could promote technological improvements, accelerate innovation, develop human capital, and facilitate trade and investment among the APEC economies. This will enable the transition to a low-carbon economy and promote the development of clean energy among APEC members.
Considering the mission of the EWG sub subgroups, the project is primarily aligned with the Clean Fossil Energy subgroup (EGCFE). This subgroup promotes the clean use of fossil fuels and advanced technologies that increase conversion efficiency and reduce environmental impact. In this sense, the project will provide insights into the challenges and experiences of converting coal-fired power plants through the implementation of ESS. Therefore, if policy changes are made taking into account these findings, environmental impacts can be reduced (e.g., air pollution can be reduced, soil pollution due to acid rain can be minimized, and workforce can be maintained, among others). In addition, the project is secondarily aligned with the New and Renewable Energy Technologies subgroup (EGNRET) by enabling an increase in the use of new and renewable energy technologies in the APEC region. Indeed, the conversion of coal-fired power plants to ESS will provide security, stability, and flexibility to renewable energy systems. It will promote the development of renewable energy in APEC economies. Consequently, the advice and experience of experts working in these subgroups will be valuable.

Beneficiaries and Outputs

Outputs

Output 1 - Seminar: The purpose of the seminar is to address experiences, challenges, and opportunities related to the conversion of coal-fired power plants in APEC economies through Energy Storage System. The event will be held in the city of Santiago, Chile, developed in person over two days, from 10 am to5 pm, approximately. The suggested date is Tuesday 27 and Wednesday28 of August 2024. The participation of 10 experts or speakers (10 funded speakers and 4 government officials) and 50 participants is expected. The target audience includes specialists, researchers, representatives of energy trade associations, professionals from energy companies, policy-makers, and authorities from APEC economies. The seminar will be an interactive event, with presentations, discussions, and interactions between participants and experts. The seminar will not be recorded.

The tentative agenda for the seminar includes:

a) Day 1:
Topic 1: Opportunities and Lessons Learned from the Conversion of Coal-fired Power Plants through ESS. Three expert presentations and panel discussions.

Topic 2: Policy Design and Regulatory Challenges in Thermal Power Plant Closure and Conversion. Two expert presentations and panel discussions.

b) Day 2:
Topic 3: Environmental and social requirements in retrofitting thermal power plants with ESS. Three expert presentations and panel discussions.

Topic 4: New Business Opportunities through Coal Power Plant Conversion. Two expert presentations and panel discussions.

Output 2 - Summary Report: A summary report will be prepared by the Chilean Ministry of Energycontaining the main findings and recommendations from the presentationsand panel discussions. The document will be a minimum of 12 pages(excluding annex) and will be submitted to APEC prior to the completiondate.

Preliminary information included to be included in the report:
a)Executive Summary.
b)Table of Contents.
c)Introduction.
d)Objectives.
e)General information on the APEC Forum and the APEC Support Fund.
f)General information on the event: Where and when it was held,participating APEC economies, number of participants broken down byexperts and audience, gender information, etc.
g)Summary and main findings of presentations and panel discussions, by topic.
h)Conclusions.
i)Recommendations.
j)Annex.

Outcomes

1) Acquisition of technical knowledge: The primary expected outcome of this project is to provide participants fromAPEC economies with technical knowledge that can support the adaptation or even creation of policies and regulations related to the conversion of coal-fired power plants by Energy Storage Systems. This will accelerate the energy transition, improve the security and stability of the electricity supply, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and minimize the impact of climate change. This outcome will be measured by the ex-ante and ex-post surveys as “the percentage of participants reporting a significant increase in knowledge” and “the percentage of APEC economies reporting a significant increase in knowledge.

2) Promoting policy design and regulatory development: It is expected that by applying the recommendations of the summary report, APEC economies could improve or redesign their policies and/or regulations based on the experiences of others. As a result, they could sustain local economies, retain some of the workforce, and avoid or reduce environmental, economic, and social impacts by retrofitting existing thermal power plants. This outcome will be measured by the ex-ante and the ex-post surveys as "the percentage of APEC developing economies that are likely to implement recommendations".

3) Creating business opportunities: The third outcome is to facilitate business opportunities among APEC economies to develop and implement thermal power plant retrofits through ESS. This outcome will be measured by the ex-ante and the ex-post surveys as “the percentage of APEC economies that foresee business opportunities among members”.

Beneficiaries: The direct beneficiaries are representatives, experts and policy-makers from APEC member economies who attend to the Seminar, as well as those representatives, experts and policy-makers from APEC member economies who can use the project outputs to create or improve their policies and regulations on coal power plant retrofits through ESS. All of them can benefit from the project because it promotes innovation and equitable development, reduces economic disparities by democratizing access to information; deepens the sense of community spirit by being an instance in which all APEC economies can participate, and can create business opportunities among them. All the people living in the economies that will use or implement the project′s recommendations will benefit indirectly. Indeed, because of Seminar topics implementation in their economies policies, they will enjoy a better quality of life as a result of the end of coal as a fuel, and will also be able to promote renewable energy by ensuring a permanent supply of electricity through ESS, allowing the reuse of existing infrastructure, helping to sustain local economies, and retaining some of the workforce.

Dissemination

A summary report (electronic publication) will be prepared in accordance with EWG standards before the project completion date. APEC will then disseminate the document by publishing it on its website. The summary report will be an APEC publication and will follow its corresponding guidelines. It will include the content proposed in Section
B - outputs (Summary report).

The primary target audience for this product is the representatives of the APEC economies who participated in the seminar as experts and audience, as well as other professionals from these economies who are interested in the topic analyzed. For example: experts, researchers, representatives of energy trade associations, professionals from energy companies, policy-makers, and authorities, etc.

Gender

The Chilean Ministry of Energy has a gender agenda that aims to promote gender parity in the energy industry. In addition, the Chilean Ministry of Energy and the Ministry of Economy recently launched the Women Add program which encourages and ensures the participation of women in the energy sector in expert panels, news, and events related to energy issues, to gradually move towards parity. Efforts will therefore be made to promote the equal participation of men and women as workers, managers, and experts or speakers at events.
A gender-balanced team is involved in the design of this project and we will continue to seek the involvement of women in the planning and implementation of the project. In this sense, at the stage of “expression of interest to present at the seminar” (see Workplan in section C), experts must indicate whether the presentation can be given by a woman, a man, or both. The PO will rank the expressions of interest according to the theme identified in section B - output (Seminar) and will then assess gender in terms of equality. In addition, the organizers will develop a contact list and a stakeholder map to include female participants as a target group.
It is expected that the project will build capacity and inspire innovation among experts and participants, whether women or men.It also seeks to promote women′s leadership through the equal participation of experts attending the seminar. Sponsoringeconomies will be encouraged to invite women leaders to participate as speakers and participants. The PO is committed to collecting sex disaggregated data for all speakers and participants (not only those funded by APEC) at the project event. This data will be included when submitting a Completion Report to the Secretariat upon completion of the project, as well as providing guidance to future POs on their own gender parity targets. In addition, the PO will commit to achieving an ideal gender balance of equal representation of both experts and participants.

Gender Participation Target Goals
Male: 50% (as Participants), 50% (as Speakers/Experts)
Female: 50% (as Participants), 50% (as Speakers/Experts)

Pillars of the Gender Criteria:
Skills, Capacity Building and Health Leadership, Voice and Agency
Innovation and Technology

Work Plan

Please refer to Project Proposal posted in "Project Proposal" of Supporting Tab.

Risks

Please refer to Project Proposal posted in "Project Proposal" of Supporting Documents Tab.

Monitoring and Evaluation

Please refer to Project Proposal posted in "Project Proposal" of Supporting Documents Tab.

Linkages

Please refer to Project Proposal posted in "Project Proposal" of Supporting Documents Tab.

Sustainability

Please refer to Project Proposal posted in "Project Proposal" of Supporting Documents Tab.

Direct Labour

Please refer to Project Proposal posted in "Project Proposal" of Supporting Documents Tab.

Are there any supporting document attached?

No
Project No.
Project Title
Project Status
Fund Account
Sub-fund
Project Year
Project Session
APEC Funding
Co-funding Amount
Total Project Value
Sponsoring Forum
Topics
Committee
Other Fora Involved
Other Non-APEC Stakeholders Involved
Proposing Economy(ies)
Co-Sponsoring Economies
Expected Start Date
Expected Completion Date
Project Proponent Name 1
Job Title 1
Organization 1
Telephone 1
Email 1
Project Proponent Name 2
Job Title 2
Organization 2
Telephone 2
Email 2
Declaration
Project Summary
Relevance
Objectives
Alignment
Beneficiaries and Outputs
Dissemination
Gender
Work Plan
Risks
Monitoring and Evaluation
Linkages
Sustainability
Direct Labour
Are there any supporting document attached?
hdFldAdmin
Project Number
Previous Fora
Secretariat Comments
Reprogramming Notes
Consolidated QAF
Endorsement By Fora
PD Sign Off
Batch
Forum Priority
Committee Ranking Category
Committee Priority
PDM Priority
Priority Within Funding Category
Monitoring Report Received
Completion Report Received
PMU Field 1
PMU Field 2
PMU Field 3
On Behalf Of
Proposal Status
Originating Sub-Forum
Approval Status
Attachments
Content Type: Standard Proposal