Sign In
APEC Project Database

Project Title

Enhancing Logistics Performance through Training and Networking for APEC Local / Regional Logistics Sub-Providers

Project Year

2012

Project Number

M CTI 01 2012T

Project Session

Session 2

Project Type

Multi-Year

Project Status

Withdrawn Project

Project No.

M CTI 01 2012T

Project Title

*
Enhancing Logistics Performance through Training and Networking for APEC Local / Regional Logistics Sub-Providers

Project Status

Withdrawn Project

Fund Account

*
TILF Special Account

Sub-fund

None

Project Year

2012

Project Session

*
Session 2

Sponsoring Forum

*
Committee on Trade and Investment (CTI)

Topics

Trade Facilitation

Committee

Committee on Trade and Investment (CTI)

Other Fora Involved

Small and Medium Enterprises Working Group (SMEWG)

Other Non-APEC Stakeholders Involved

 

Proposing Economy(ies)

China

Co-Sponsoring Economies

Brunei Darussalam; Chile; Hong Kong, China; Indonesia; Papua New Guinea; Peru; Russia; Singapore; Chinese Taipei; Thailand; United States

Expected Start Date

*
01/08/2012

Expected Completion Date

*
31/12/2014

APEC Funding

*
498,025

Co-funding Amount

*
201,090

Co-funding Percentage

28.76%

Total Project Value

699,115

Project Proponent Name 1

*
Mr Yang Zhengwei (wef June 2015)

Job Title 1

*
Department of International Trade and Economic Affairs

Organization 1

*
Ministry of Commerce

Telephone 1

*
86-10 6519 7779

Email 1

*

Project Proponent Name 2

Not Applicable

Job Title 2

Not Applicable

Organization 2

Not Applicable

Telephone 2

Not Applicable

Email 2

Not Applicable

Declaration

*
Mr Yang Zhengwei

Project Summary

*

As expressed in the November 2010 Leaders’ Statement in Yokohama, Japan, “Businesses have become larger and multinational in scope, tapping into supply chains that transcend traditional economic and geographic boundaries.”  In addition, Ministers endorsed the Supply Chain Connectivity Framework Action Plan in 2010, and later research as per suggestions laid out in the Action Plan for Chokepoint 3 revealed that SME Logistics Service Providers (LSPs) in the region lack capacity to provide cross-border logistics services consistent with the supply chain needs of new and evolving international business developments. LSPs are a group responsible for a broad scope of supply chain related services including international transport (land, air and sea), terminal handling, cargo consolidation, customs clearance, warehousing, and include 3rd party as well as integrated logistics service providers. The large majority of SME LSPs surveyed in 2010 continue to operate local supply chains limited to their own economy and borders, while foreign economy information, policies, standards and trade related resources remain unknown and/or inaccessible.

Goals Summary:

This initiative is an endeavor to (1) improve awareness of the changing international business situation, (2) promote awareness and understanding of supply chain relevant policies and regulations in each APEC economy, and (3) promote awareness and proficiency in modern cross-border supply chain practices and advanced logistics technologies; all in an effort to facilitate supply chain cost reduction, build potential for faster and easier execution of cross-border trade, and improve the cross-border logistics environment. These goals are focused with engaging the SME LSP player, and will be accomplished by:

1.    Research and development of a logistics supply chain model that places development of SME LSP capabilities and potential in the context of a changing international business situation and emerging logistics technologies and practices – results and conclusions presented in the ILS Logistics Supply Chain Model Preliminary Overview report;

2.    Utilizing this model as a foundation for development of an APEC wide LSP mechanism that will facilitate knowledge sharing, support utilization and understanding of participating APEC economies’ logistics related resources (policies, regulations, government and logistics association support, etc.), and  promote communication between LSPs and relevant government and support organizations – the International Logistics Support (ILS) network;

3.    Holding two conference events that will (1) serve to further supplement research and development of the SME LSP focused logistics supply chain model and thus the ILS network with expert input on logistics technologies and modern modes of logistics and supply chain operation; (2) provide a forum to engage participating logistics technology and logistics model experts in a colloquium to advance and refine the ILS network in development – ILS Network Development Colloquium; (3) provide a forum to gain feedback on the ILS network from the entire APEC community; and (4) additionally serve as an opportunity to train organizations responsible for educating LSPs in their respective economies in the knowledge gained throughout the fulfillment of this initiative – Train the Trainers.

The ultimate goal of this initiative will be completion of the web accessible International Logistics Support (ILS) pilot network. This tool represents a sustainable mechanism supporting long-term SME LSP awareness building, capacity improvement, and communication among LSPs and logistics support organizations across the APEC region. It represents a culmination of all the above undertakings, and will be designed to achieve deepened understanding of policy, regulations and logistics processes across economies. The ILS network will ultimately enhance the ability of SME LSPs to provide efficient cross-border logistics supply chain services by providing them with relevant cross-economy information and support with regard to the cross-border trade action of which they are engaging. The network will draw usage by providing a tool that allows SME LSPs to better utilize their existing internal resources and capabilities, and by way of coordination and alignment present information in localized format to afford logistics processes support. This mechanism of LSP facilitation represents an approach to simplifying cross-border trade at the level of logistics processes by providing a centralized means of accessing policies and regulations across economies, and improving LSP ability to understand and operate according to each economy’s requirements; without the need for each economy to align themselves with one set of rules or regulations.

ILS Network Description:

The ILS network will be a cloud based organizational infrastructure with nodes for each economy. Each node will be linked and integrated with a central hub responsible for facilitating communication of cross-border policies, standards, regulations, documentation and other key information access. The central hub is also tasked with matching and converting information provided by each economy into the format that is locally used, and thus understandable by each other participating node economy. The hub is also responsible for maintaining the guidelines and standards for information quality and transfer that shall aid accomplishing this within the ILS network, and additionally will ensure duplications or inconsistencies between nodes (economies) are pointed out. The nodes are responsible for the logistics chain information within their economy, gathering relevant local supply chain information, and exchanging it with the hub according to standard guidelines for quality and information pertinence. They are also responsible for directing SME LSPs who require assistance in their economy.

An additional key benefit of the ILS pilot network is that LSPs can go to this centralized hub for logistics information in a much easier and more efficient way, which in turn will further facilitate communication of LSP needs to government organizations (through notation of information requests) and logistics associations within APEC, while providing a channel for LSPs to be quickly notified of any changes in government policy or standards within participating economies. From the point of view of government policy developers, the ILS platform serves as a window unto the relevant policies of each economy, and the questions posted by the actual LSP users as they encounter and engage in cross-border business as per each. This is a completely open platform, and policy makers will easily be able to see how well the policies of their economy complement or compare with those of other economies.

Primary Deliverables:

Implementation of this initiative is broken down into meeting two major deliverables, of which supporting undertakings will be carried out simultaneously over the 2013 – 2014 period. Both deliverables are dependent on results and conclusions arrived at in 2012 research undertakings. In many instances the following two major deliverables are co-dependent in nature; and are both working towards creating a valuable and relevant international logistics support mechanism that can sustain LSP awareness and capacity building over the long-term.

Major Deliverable 1 (Activities): Train the Trainers & ILS Network Development Colloquia Conferences – Awareness and Knowledge Building, Enhancement of Capacity for Adoption of Advanced Technology and Best Practices, and Advancing Goals Through Application of the ILS Network Tool (2013)

Research and development studies, and training courses will focus on foundational knowledge useful to promote awareness of current and emerging logistics models and business trends; as well as advanced logistics technologies and modern supply chain practices available under existing SME LSP resource availability. Results will be used for ILS network development and development of beneficial conferences. For each conference we will invite each economy to suggest participation of organizations focused on the development of LSP sub-providers, as well as those with valueable industry experience and knowledge regardless of focus group. Consistent with the Guidebook on APEC Projects (ed. 8), the selection of organizations will be based on relevance to research conducted up to that point, and with respect to identifying the best organizations suited to contributing to the goals of the training sessions, and by extension, further development of the ILS network. Coordinating and enhancing local organizations’ ability to train the trainers will be an enduringly effective and pragmatic approach to enhancing LSP sub-providers’ capacity. The longevity of this initiative’s effectiveness will be ultimately furthered with completion of the ILS network as explained in the description of Major Deliverable 2 below.. For conference sessions we will identify key SME LSP development and support bodies (e.g. local logistics associations) in each APEC economy and invite them to the events. LSP sub-providers recommended by each economy are also welcome for consideration.

Spring 2013, Suzhou, ChinaSuzhou Train the Trainers & ILS Network Development Colloquium: Promoting Awareness of Logistics Models for Emerging International Business, and Adoption of Advanced Logistics and Supply Chain Technologies

This session will focus on building awareness of new logistics models and advanced technologies, and their emerging usage in changing global supply chains as international business needs evolve. Forums held will discuss logistics model research, related technologies and their application to the ILS pilot network in development. Feedback and discussions with the entire APEC community regarding the ILS pilot network in development will also provide necessary critique and guidance. Further discussions will investigate application scenarios under SME LSP existing capabilities and realistic development potential given their prevailing financial, technical and knowledge resources.

 

Fall 2013, Indonesia –Indonesia Train the Trainers & ILS Network Development Colloquium: Promoting Awareness and Adoption of Modern Supply Chain Practices under Current APEC Economies’ Cross-border Policies and Business Environment

This session will focus on promoting awareness of modern supply chain practices, as well as gain feedback on the to-date effectiveness and design of the ILS pilot network and website usage during the trial period. Training sessions will focus on the governmental policies and overall business environments within the APEC region, and review best practices for operation in these settings. Expert review of the ILS network in trial operation will gauge the platform’s alignment to modern supply chain practices, cross-border policy and business environment. This session will further review and promote best practice examples of cross-border trade using existing SME LSP resources, and focus on how integration of the ILS pilot network may benefit these practices. Key performing logistics models will be presented, while suggested changes and improvements to the new ILS pilot network in development will be reviewed and discussed with all APEC and economy representatives in attendance.

Major Deliverable 2 (Platform): The International Logistics Support (ILS) Pilot Network (2013 – 2014)

The theoretical foundation for the ILS pilot network will be based on the ILS Logistics Supply Chain Preliminary Overview, and conference session feedback. Participating economies can decide what existing economy-wide hyperlink(s) of logistics information should be included in their respective nodes to this central hub. All hyperlinks provided by participating economies are managed and owned by the information providers. Meanwhile, existing APEC resources such as the APEC logistics website (http://www.logistics.apec.org/) or customs-related websites developed by the SCCP, for example, could also be linked with and integrated into the central hub.

For the duration of this project, we will create an initial network of the hub, and work with a few pilot economies to develop the first nodes of the ILS network. The pilot version of the ILS network will include local information on China and a few other pilot economies delivered through a website that will: ·      Provide access to information on various logistics activities
·      Present information on each economy in a format the user is accustomed to
·      Provide a tool for clear cross-economy communication initially on a selection of domestic policies and regulations from each economy, without the need for regional alignment to any one uniform policy – improving LSPs knowledge with regard to logistics policies and regulations in all participating economies


The initial funding provided for this project will be sufficient for implementing the ILS network in pilot economies. Included are development of frameworks and basic information collection, research and development of models, integration of key cross-economy policies and information analysis, facilitating location and adoption of relevant information, as well as development and maintenance of technical infrastructure for the central hub. Once established, keeping information up-to-date and costs of maintaining technical infrastructure at the level of a pilot program should be minimal. China is committed to providing operational funding of the ILS network at the level of a pilot program for the duration necessary to allow its value to the APEC whole to be justified. However, expansion of the network into more economies will depend on level of success and additional funding.

Linkages between primary deliverables:

The purpose of the two conferencesessions are to help build knowledge of advanced cross-border logistics and supply chain models, best practices and logistics technologies, while also creating an immediate short to mid-term channel to improve economies’ understanding of obstacles that LSPs may face when engaging in cross-border logistics business. With regard to the second major deliverable, these two sessions provide a discussion forum where all APEC economies will have a chance to meet together and provide critique and guidance regarding development of the ILS pilot network and related research. The undertakings in the second deliverable build on expert advice and criticism from key operations research domains within the logistics and supply chain realm, thereby leveraged from experts engaging in conference events. With a strong reference to conclusions arrived at in the first major deliverable’s undertakings, the ILS pilot network design and implementation endeavors to address obstacles LSPs face with construction of an informational portal suited to typical LSP capabilities, in which an LSP user may access logistics associations, support groups and other relevant organizational support in each economy regardless of their locality. In turn, this portal will serve as a long-term LSP awareness building and support tool, and the knowledge and usage patterns noted may further support development of future training programs by other related LSP support organizations.

Relevance

*

This multi-year initiative provides a practical solution based approach to address Chokepoint 3 identified in the APEC Supply-Chain Connectivity Action Plan as endorsed by Ministers at Yokohama in 2010. This initiative will directly contribute to the goal of a 10 percent improvement in supply chain performance by 2015, by enhancing LSP ability and capacity for cross-border logistics. The objective of this initiative aims to coordinate LSPs and resources in different economies by facilitating information sharing and improving the transparency of various regulations and policies by means of a new ILS pilot network; thereby improving the ability of APEC LSPs to operate across borders. This approach works to improve LSP capabilities without requiring significant increases in LSP internal resources. As a result LSP ROI will increase due to refocusing limited resources on core business growth, while time and resources spent locating and identifying relevant information needed for cross-border trade should be significantly reduced. The goals of this initiative are also in line with the APEC-2012 priorities of Establishing reliable supply chains’.

Supply chain infrastructure and its supporting logistics entities are the backbone of sustainable business in any economy. And as basic resources including fuel, labor, financial and other support systems become ever more limited, the need for efficiency increases and streamlining supply channels becomes paramount. Yet, the typical SME LSP is already limited in its ability to adapt and grow with changing business and regulatory environments.

The two conferences serve as a channel to support the development of an open access tool to build awareness of current circumstances and develop sustainable solutions utilizing modern supply chain practices and advanced logistics technologies, while at the same time offer an ancillary short to mid-term aid to awareness building via training sessions.

Works devoted to the ILS mechanism focus on developing a long-term solution that meets SME LSP circumstances with a new logistics model for information sharing and support that will contribute to improved cross-border logistics performance to match evolving needs; with implementation through an online and offline framework of resources and tools. The ILS network should meet the goals of the Supply-Chain Connectivity framework while additionally providing more consistent access to information about the performance of SME LSPs in the region.

This initiative concludes with the ILS pilot network as a collaboration platform to assist LSPs in various economies to form the complete cross-border supply chain, better utilize existing logistics resources within each economy and develop logistics “bridges” between LSPs in different economies. A LSP of one economy will be able to identify and work with the relevant government or non-government logistics organization of foreign economies. Each organization may then assist or redirect the LSP accordingly. The ILS network should serve as a reliable framework to promote SME LSP inter-economy cooperation and reliable, efficient SME focused supply chain operations.

Simultaneously the ILS network can influence policy development in each economy based on the consistencies and inconsistencies revealed across APEC economies. As the ILS mechanism matches and identifies related trade policies and regulations, inconsistent or overlapping policies will be clearly revealed, and policy makers can use this information to better design their own economy’s policy – having a clear view of how it may interact with other economies and APEC as a whole. Information gathered through ILS pilot network usage can serve as a key information and logistics performance resource for other APEC fora designing strategies to promote regional development within their respective domains.

Objectives

*

The core aim of this initiative is to carry out and integrate research and first-hand experience concerning the current logistics supply chain situation as it applies to the APEC SME LSP into an open and useful International Logistics Support network. This will be achieved by implementing this initiative via meeting several concurring and complimentary objectives:


1.
   
Perform research and development of a supply chain model that can support emerging international business structures given existing SME LSP resources.

This primarily involves a literature review of relevant research, and conducting field interviews and discussion events in participating pilot economies.

A key deliverable will be the ILS Logistics Supply Chain Preliminary Overview report.

2. Develop and deliver an online and offline open access tool to support SME LSP awareness, education, capacity enhancement and communication support – the ILS mechanism.

This involves using the ILS Logistics Supply Chain Preliminary Overview as a theoretical foundation for an APEC wide logistics support network. It also involves integrating expert input gained through colloquia and APEC wide feedback gained through APEC conference forum discussions. (See objective below) It further involves developing the technical support infrastructure and a website access portal to facilitate usage in all economies. Content development involves integrating existing cross-border trade platforms, selection and conversion of relevant cross-economy regulations and policy, and compilation into a universally accessible format (in some cases this will involve translation).

A key deliverable will be the ILS pilot network and its website access portal.

3. Hold two APEC conferences that will provide a channel to refine the ILS network in development and build awareness of logistics technologies, models and modern supply chain practices in relation to the current international business environment and the SME LSP.

This involves planning and implementing two events in China and Indonesia that include Train the Trainers sessions, ILS Network Development Colloquia, and identifying and acquiring participation of relevant expert speakers on logistics technologies and models, as well as modern supply chain practices.

Key deliverables will be successful completion of two conferences, and the compilation of feedback and recommendations from the training session participants and the colloquia experts.

Multi-Year Approach

*
The key motivation for electing the multi-year approach is the holistic and on-going nature of the initiative. 2012 research focuses on establishing the theoretical basis for the ILS network in the context of the SME LSP resources situation and performance needs. Development of the actual network is scheduled to ensue while two training sessions/discussion forums are held in 2013 to simultaneously serve as a channel to supplement research with expert input on leading technologies and models in the context of SME LSP needs, and advise how to leverage the ILS network.Conferences will further provide two opportunities for the APEC body as a whole to view progress and suggest improvements or offer advice. The conferences will additionally provide an opportunity to train relevant organizations in all knowledge gained throughout implementation of the initiative over the past two years. The APEC body is an ideal organization to implement this type of project due to the need for direct involvement and support from multiple economies and organizations at both the governmental and non-governmental levels; the multi-year approach particularly supports this broad participation of stakeholders.

The objectives of this initiative are both short and long-term, and the results need to be collected and monitored over an extended period. The multi-year approach allows for the consistent and ongoing involvement of the stakeholders, and further the ability to address the dynamic nature of the logistics industry across the region as requirements change with changing environment over time.

Moreover, this project will create a model framework in a few pilot economies that can be duplicated and extended over time as its success is weighed with investment. At this early stage there is already agreement with many economies including China; Hong Kong, China; Chinese Taipei; Singapore; and the United States on some vital SME LSP development needs and the need to implement policies improving the business environment; moreover, interest is growing particularly in developing economies. APEC Multi-Year Project funding will be critical to ensuring opportunities for broad, inclusive participation through 2015.

Beneficiaries and Outputs

*

As described in Summary section, this initiative targets SME LSPs in the APEC region. Direct enhancement of their capabilities and efficiency will result in an indirect enhancement of regional international business as a whole.

In the short and mid-term, training session workshops will aid in training organizations responsible for SME LSP education in their home economies. This will aid in quickly disseminating the latest developments in logistics technologies, practices and supply chain models along with their potential usage in each SME LSP economy. As such these sessions should encourage immediate improvement in regional supply chain performance.  

Long term effects will be achieved by the information resources and support services made available through the ILS network. SME LSPs will acquire more flexibility and be better able to focus resources based on global and regional information made accessible locally through the network. These operations optimizations will free SME internal resources to focus on growing core business and expanding cross-border abilities and capacity. Finally, all research deliverables from this initiative will be made available through the APEC network, and can be built upon to develop future initiatives

Dissemination

*

All project deliverables will be distributed freely to the general public. This initiative involves the participation of numerous APEC and Non-APEC stakeholders, and by this very nature will be openly distributed.

All reports and survey conclusions will be distributed through the APEC network.

Gender

*
Women were involved in the development of this project proposal, and will be involved in both decision making and direct labor levels during project implementation. Project results will benefit women both directly and indirectly.

Work Plan

*

Q3 & Q4 2012 – Research and develop SME centered basic supply chain model

Research into the foundational model for the ILS network will be conducted through literature review and field study in the form of discussion fora, expert interviews and surveys in each pilot APEC economy. APEC fora and other non-APEC organizations (e.g. WTO, ASEAN, UNESCAP) involved in projects with goals that are in line with the ILS network concept will be involved as advisors, contributors or both.

Relevant undertakings required to meet this objective include:

1.    Completion of a literature review of current logistics and supply chain research;
2.    Field research in each participating pilot economy, and involves:

a.   Interviewing LSPs, relevant government and non-government organizations, and businesses involved in cross-border operations

b.   Holding discussion forums in each pilot economy where relevant cross-border policy makers and LSP participants can share experience and offer guidance regarding development of an accurate logistics model, and thereby the ILS network’s theoretical foundation.

c.   Identifying key experts in each economy that will be of value to both the ILS Development Colloquia and Train the Trainers sessions later on in the initiative.

3.    Compilation of research and conclusions into a report, the ILS Logistics Supply Chain Model Preliminary Overview. This report will be presented for comments and revision at the Suzhou conference in Spring 2013 prior to publishing on the APEC website.

Q1 & Q2 2013 – Establishment of initial ILS Pilot Network Hub and Nodes; Launch of ILS Website Portal; and prepare the “Suzhou Train the Trainers & ILS Network Development” conference event

Utilize experience and relationships with experts developed during 2012 research endeavors to organize a valuable Suzhou Train the Trainers & ILS Network Development Colloquium session. Concepts previously developed for the ILS network model will be presented during discussion fora and will complement training sessions focused on Promoting Awareness of Logistics Models for Emerging International Business and Adoption of Advanced Logistics and Supply Chain Technologies. Key experts consulted during 2012 research will also be invited to weigh in on the resulting ILS network in development, and be available to offer feedback and suggestions for further development.


Relevant undertakings required to meet these objectives include:

1.    Establishment of the pilot ILS network organizational framework and gaining local support in each participating economy. This involves:

a.    Organizing the establishment of node network elements within pilot economies.

b.    Working with local logistics associations and other related organizations in each pilot economy to push awareness and benefits of the new network, and encourage pre-launch testing of the pilot network by a select group of representative SME LSPs.

c.    Developing standard operating procedures, core processes, and the basic information relational model to support cross-economy integration and the manifold structure to support the successful integration of heterogeneous network platforms across APEC and non-APEC participating groups.

2.    Development of the ILS network’s initial core functions based on SME LSP logistics and supply chain information and service needs as determined by this initiative’s 2012 research. This involves:

a.    Developing the initial technical infrastructure to support the ILS pilot network. This includes.

i.     Database design
ii.    Internetwork communication protocol specification development
iii.  Basic server design
iv.  Website portal design

b.    Gathering initial information and feedback from local sources to integrate into the pilot ILS network.

c.
Selection and organization (including possible translation) of related information into a usable medium as defined by undertaking 1c above.

3.      Identifying key experts that will be beneficial to further ILS network refinement and are also willing to aid in designing effective training sessions.

4.      Working with experts to organize and design beneficial training sessions based on the conference topics.

Work at this stage will culminate in the development and launch of the ILS website, which will serve as the primary access portal to the network. This deliverable is free and open for use by any interested party the world over, however information and support services are tailored to the needs of the APEC SME Logistics Service Provider. The Suzhou Train the Trainers & ILS Network Development Colloquium conference will provide the entire APEC community with an opportunity to review and comment on the ILS network in development.

Train the Trainers sessions will utilize research findings regarding SME LSP’s logistics model and supply chain technology usage to develop relevant materials. Aided with expert input, training courses will be developed with the following goals:


1.      Educate on deficiencies and advantages existing in the relationship between the APEC SME LSP and current logistics supply chain operating models.

2.      Educate on current nature of SME LSP logistics technology usage in the region, and key underlying reasons.

3.      Introduce new logistics models and new approaches to SME LSP operation within existing logistics models that maximize operating efficiency under limited resource availability.

4.      Introduce advanced logistics and supply chain technologies, along with implementation schemes targeted at the SME LSP user.

5.      Review and recommend methods that participants can best take advantage of for delivering knowledge resources to the SME LSPs in their respective economies.

Participants will be persons from each economy responsible for aiding SME LSPs, and may include program developers from local logistics associations, logistics and supply chain government support groups, and/or relevant non-government support groups. They will be chosen by the PO based on the following process:


1.      Request recommendations from each economy for participants based on Guidelines for Participant Selection. This document will express details of the training session content once developed, and communicate the responsibilities and expectations we have of each participant in order to hold a beneficial training course.

2.      Based on training course criteria select participants from each economy that will be best suited to benefit from the course, and extend the knowledge resources gained to the SME LSPs in their respective economies.

Trained trainers returning to their home economies will be supplied with evaluation surveys developed to gauge SME LSP performance before and after implementation of the methods reviewed during the training session. Data from these informal surveys will also be used to guide the fall 2013 training session, and well as refine ILS network requirements.


Q3 & Q4 2013 – Prepare Indonesia Train the Trainers & ILS Network Development Colloquium conference; gather feedback on near complete pilot phase of the ILS Network and present results and reactions from first SME LSP users of the network

The second major conference of this initiative will focus on ensuring the ILS network is meeting the needs of the SME LSP, conforms to usage patterns of modern supply chain practices operating within the current policy and business environment, and provide an opportunity for final feedback from key experts and the APEC community as whole as the ILS pilot network enters its final stage of development. As with the first conference, full advantage will be taken of the presence of both supply chain experts and organizations responsible for SME LSP development in each economy by organizing a second Train the Trainers session designed to promote the knowledge acquired during initiative endeavors so far. Participation of experts involved in the development of innovative and successful cross-border logistics models will further boost awareness of current policies and business environment, and provide guidance on best practices given a realistic assessment of current international business requirements. Participation of these parties and feedback on the ILS pilot network in development will all contribute to an effective workshop Promoting Awareness and Adoption of Modern Supply Chain Practices under Current APEC Economies’ Cross-border Policies and Business Environment.


Relevant undertakings required to meet these objectives include:

1.      Identifying key experts that will be beneficial to further ILS network refinement and are also willing to aid in designing effective training sessions.

2. Working
with experts to organize and design beneficial training sessions based on the conference topics.

3.      Gathering feedback and reactions from SME LSP test users of the ILS network in development. Compiling this information and drawing conclusions which will be presented during the conference.

4.      Organize the colloquium session to engage experts and participants in discussion to identify ways to refine the ILS mechanism and further its congruity to the business and logistics environments of each economy.

Train the Trainers sessions will utilize research findings regarding SME LSP’s involvement in global supply chains and major regulatory difficulties contributing to inhibited cross-border operations capacity to develop relevant training materials. Aided with expert input, training courses will be developed with the following goals:

1.      Educate on the effects of current supply chain operational requirements and current regulatory schemes on the typical APEC SME LSP.

2.      Introduce modern supply chain practices that are successful under current cross-border policy and business environments

3.      Present an approach to SME LSP engagement of these modern supply chain practices given their limited resources and development capacities. This may involve expert engagement to modify select modern supply chain practices to suit the needs of an SME LSP.

4.      Use Spring 2013 informal survey results to modify and present implementation schemes that will aid participants in furthering teachings to the SME LSP user in their respective economies.

Participants will be persons from each economy responsible for aiding SME LSPs, and may include program developers from local logistics associations, logistics and supply chain government support groups, and/or relevant non-government support groups. They will be chosen by the PO based on the following process:



1.      Request recommendations from each economy for participants based on Guidelines for Participant Selection. This document will express details of the training session content once developed, and communicate the responsibilities and expectations we have of each participant in order to hold a beneficial training course.

2.      Based on training course criteria select participants from each economy that will be best suited to benefit from the course, and extend the knowledge resources gained to the SME LSPs in their respective economies.

Trained trainers returning to their home economies will be supplied with evaluation surveys developed to gauge SME LSP performance before and after implementation of the methods reviewed during the training session. Data from these informal surveys will also be used to further refine ILS network requirements.

2014 – Refine ILS Network and Prepare Final Initiative Report

Initiative work in this year will focus on refining the ILS pilot network, and preliminary planning for expansion of scope. Usage and effectiveness metrics will be collected over the year, and evaluations made to determine estimated ROI for the project. Results will be reported to the APEC Secretariat, and discussion will begin regarding expansion of the network into other APEC economies and beyond.

Relevant undertakings required to meet these objectives include:

1.      Modify any ILS network elements to conform to suggestions gained from Indonesia colloquium. This many involve anything from altering organizational structure, technical structure, information presentation format, or overall selection of information.

2.      Analyze data complied over the time of network operation and gather conclusions to be presented in the final initiative report.

3.      Based on reactions and results of the pilot ILS network, develop a preliminary overview of potential for expansion of the network’s scope and expansion into other economies.


4.  Report all conclusions in a Final Initiative Report and offer to the APEC community for suggestions prior to publishing on the APEC website.

Risks

*

Risks surrounding implementation of technological infrastructures are negligible, as we will be utilizing relatively mature technologies and contracting industry experts to develop the technical platform. This initiative has proposed to specifically contract experts in each field including database design, network infrastructure design, information protocol design and implementation as well as website design. The presence of experts in each technical field, and the maturity of the technology utilized lead us to conclude risk due to technological issues and multi-tier integration of all elements is negligible.

There may be minimal risk in ensuring the participation of many parties across APEC and non-APEC groups (e.g. WTO, UN, ASEAN, etc.), as well ensuring cooperation of various resources from different participating economies. Engagement and ownership of other economies in the delivery of key variables is critical for the success of this initiative, however many such parties were involved from the beginning in project planning, and we have sought out input from many future stakeholders in this initiative. This proposal has been modified significantly to ensure active interest and participation from all participating future parties. The proposal in its present form represents plausible objectives and productive participation from all groups involved can be reasonably expected – non-participation is a minimal risk factor.

Due diligence has been observed in the development of this initiative and any risks arising from technology integration related to the development of the ILS pilot network or by participation of multiple stakeholders has been sufficiently minimized and adequately managed. Advice has been sought for project planning and includes suggestions from other economies including Peru, Chinese Taipei, Russia and Hong Kong, China.

Monitoring and Evaluation

*

Project overseers, will regularly monitor the progress and impacts of the initiative’s activities on both stakeholders and non-stakeholders. This will be accomplished by status reviews, training course performance questionnaires, and feedback from partner economies engaged in the pilot program of the ILS network. There will be a constant focus on ensuring the platform development trajectory is ideal; with continued gauging of the project’s ability to meet evolving and future goals. Review and evaluation of the two completed training sessions, and successfully implementing the ILS pilot network website are key measureable deliverables. Further, the ILS pilot network itself will generate usage statistics which will be periodically reported once implementation occurs. Additionally, project overseers will develop a performance monitoring plan that can be aligned with the initiative to help monitor and evaluate whether the project is meeting its intended objectives.

Successful completion of each training session in 2013 will serve as milestones to progress in which all APEC economies will be involved in critique and evaluation. As the theoretical basis for the ILS pilot network will be built upon research to be evaluated and refined in each successive training session, these sessions shall simultaneously serve as proof of ILS pilot network development at each stage.

Each stage of this project builds on previous stages, and this will inherently ensure completion of all objectives as time progresses. Further, the involvement of independent parties in all stages ensures unbiased input and review will be available at any point during initiative execution.

Linkages

*

Other fora: What role will they play in the planning and implementation of the project? How will they share in the benefits?

The objectives of this project have clear synergies with the agenda of the SME Working Group (SMEWG), and intersect with the SMEWG’s capacity building program and the goals of APEC as a whole. This project follows research conducted in “Programme for Enhancing the Capacity of APEC Local/Regional Logistics Sub-providers”, as well as other research such as “Customs Import Automation – A Pilot Project for SMEs and OEMs”, “Survey of Supply Chain Workforce Development Needs” and the seminars conducted on “Managing Operations and Risk in International Global Supply Chain Operations” to develop a practical solution to Chokepoint 3 of the SCC Framework.

Other APEC fora such as SCCP, TPTWG and ISTWG will also play an important role in identifying current APEC resources, trade facilitation needs and defining an implementation strategy in each pilot economy where ILS pilot network nodes will be established. This project aims to integrate and collaborate, rather than duplicate work already done in each fora, and moreover aims to identify other non-APEC resources that can be integrated into a consistent International Logistics Support network across APEC. In particular this initiative will integrate and build on efforts by WTO, WCO and UN/CEFACT among others.

Non-APEC stakeholders: What role will external stakeholders play in the planning and implementation of the project? How will they share in the benefits?

The SME logistics provider, other international organizations, and key experts in various logistics and technology fields will be the key non-APEC stakeholders directly involved in this initiative. They will provide experts knowledge and advice that will be disseminated through training sessions. Further, completion of Part 2 of this project will require heavily involved research and planning in many different economies, and input from these non-APEC stakeholders will be important in the development of the logistics supply chain model and International Logistics Support network infrastructure.

These non-APEC stakeholders and the APEC region in general will all share in the benefits of reduced overall cost of doing business for the average SME who hires an SME LSP utilizing the system. By lowering the SME LSP barrier to engaging in cross-border supply chain activities, ILS usage will translate into increased ROI for the average SME as limited resources are refocused away from locating and identifying relevant information, and directed to core business growth. This should result in an overall increase in efficiency and sustainable cross-border trade for the region.

Previous work: How does this project build on, rather than duplicate, previous or ongoing initiatives in APEC or other organisations?

While focusing on advanced technology and modern supply chain practices, Part 1 of this project takes special care to integrate current logistics business situational needs and existing SME LSP resource capabilities to develop programs that are truly beneficial in the short and medium-term. These training sessions will not only build awareness of new technologies or practices, but moreover establish an understanding of how these advanced assets can be utilized given the typical SME LSP situation.

It should be emphasized that Part 2 of this initiative does not aim to build an information warehouse or database website, as there are already several similar tools in existence with limited usage. This project is specifically designed to identify and integrate current research, projects and other initiatives that already exist in the logistics facilitation realm. This information will be integrated into a framework that can be easily extended in each economy based on local requirements and logistics needs, and further integrated into the APEC managed whole – creating a unified and reliable cross-border logistics support hub where each economy involved is owner and manager of integrated nodes within the entire ILS network.

APEC’s comparative advantage: Why is APEC the best sources of fund for this project?

The goals of this initiative are well aligned with the goals of APEC as articulated as early as 1995 in the Osaka Action Agenda. There already has been a significant amount of work done in APEC towards reaching objectives in OAA and Bogor Goals, and this project is an ideal vehicle to integrate current progress into an accessible format such that the key non-APEC stakeholders: SMEs can easily and effectively benefit from all this work.

Further, the open and voluntary nature of the APEC institution is ideal for such an overarching initiative as this.

Project Management

*

Key project deliverables necessary for the initiative to move forward will be expressly delineated in contracts with contracted parties. As such, initiative completion is guaranteed. Additionally, the project overseers have specifically indicated development of a project monitoring plan as a key and early deliverable that will ensure the initiative’s successful completion regardless of the PO situation. Further, the project overseer is not expected to change during the duration of the initiative.

Sustainability

*

The funds requested for this project are sufficient to hold two training sessions and cover the development of the pilot Hub and Nodes in participating pilot economies. Once development of the pilot ILS network is complete, content will be generated and supported by the users as they interact with each other. Advisory material and other such support content are self-generated by participating logistics organizations, government institutions and LSP users.

Funding requested for this initiative will support development of the ILS pilot network for the duration of the MYP. China is prepared to fund maintenance costs of this project for the duration of the pilot stage, up until the value and benefits of the network to APEC LSPs can be justified. Success of the project and demonstrated value should justify further network growth into other economies, and therefore appeal for additional funding considerations


After completion of the ILS network, monitoring and evaluation is covered by initial funding for one year. This will include publishing success elements and ensuring the benefits of the project are well known. The success of the network and actual level of ROI will support future interest and funding; and spur further development and expansion into other APEC economies.

Completion of this initiative serves as a results oriented proof-of-concept project. The concept underlying the ILS mechanism was first presented after the presentation of results of the survey study done for the 2010 Programme for Enhancing the Capacity of APEC Local / Regional Logistics Sub-providers conference. There was strong interest from all participating economies at the time, and included participants from Chile; China; Chinese Taipei; Hong Kong, China; Indonesia; Malaysia; Mexico; Peru; Papua New Guinea; the Philippines; the Russian Federation; Singapore; Thailand; the United States and Viet Nam. Further support for the concept was gained after further discussion with APEC participants later in San Francisco and Hawaii during the 2011 APEC USA events. Strong support from the APEC community overall, as well as further consultation with non-APEC logistics related groups has led us to present this initiative proposal with confidence.

The basic infrastructure completed by this initiative represents the bulk of difficulty and cost related to the ILS mechanism. Expansion into other economies will involve further information gathering and matching/management undertakings, but will be significantly less intensive than the works described in this proposal. As such, we believe successful completion of the pilot ILS network along with the limited additional resource requirements for expansion will lead to strong interest and high probability for support from other economies interested in further developing the network.

Direct Labour

*

Contractors experienced in relevant fields of work necessary for project undertakings and the development of ILS will be contracted for the research and development of this project. A significant portion of funding will be devoted to labor involved in researching specific LSP logistics supply chain requirements, collecting relevant information, analyzing data, developing an information delivery structure and formatting relevant data into usable information.

The expertise required for the development of the ILS network is very broad, and includes development of technical infrastructures, collection and organization of information related to cross-border operations from multiple economies, and effective design of an information infrastructure that will support useful integration of information from multiple sources into an easy to use delivery vehicle. Specific details on contracted parties are unavailable at this time

Are there any supporting document attached?

No
Project No.
Project Title
Project Status
Fund Account
Sub-fund
Project Year
Project Session
Sponsoring Forum
Topics
Committee
Other Fora Involved
Other Non-APEC Stakeholders Involved
Proposing Economy(ies)
Co-Sponsoring Economies
Expected Start Date
Expected Completion Date
APEC Funding
Co-funding Amount
Co-funding Percentage
Total Project Value
Project Proponent Name 1
Job Title 1
Organization 1
Telephone 1
Email 1
Project Proponent Name 2
Job Title 2
Organization 2
Telephone 2
Email 2
Declaration
Project Summary
Relevance
Objectives
Multi-Year Approach
Beneficiaries and Outputs
Dissemination
Gender
Work Plan
Risks
Monitoring and Evaluation
Linkages
Project Management
Sustainability
Direct Labour
Are there any supporting document attached?
hdFldAdmin
Project Number
Approval Status
Attachments
Content Type: MYP Proposal